From our ovens to your doorstep
Authentic NYC Bagels Shipped Nationwide
Our bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled and baked in small batches in the East Village, using five ingredients and a recipe that dates back to the 1950s. Now you can have them shipped anywhere in the country through Goldbelly. Order a baker’s dozen, add our house-made cream cheese and lox, or send a full New York brunch to someone who’s been missing one.
Baked in New York
East Village originals
Ships nationwide
Through Goldbelly
Choose your date
See available delivery dates
Send a bagel gift
A real taste of home
New York, wherever you are
Get New York Bagels Delivered to Your Door
You can leave New York, but the bagel cravings follow you. If you moved away and never found a bagel with the same chew and crackly crust, this is the fix. Pick your flavors, and a box of our bagels ships straight from the East Village to your kitchen.
It works the other way too. Send a Sunday brunch to your parents in Phoenix, a care package to a kid at college, or a thank-you to a friend who’s never had a real New York bagel. Stock your freezer with a couple dozen so the good stuff is always one toaster away. However you use it, the bagels are the same ones our regulars line up for on Avenue A.
Choose your box
Shop Our Nationwide Bagel Shipping Packages
Every package is made by Tompkins Square Bagels and shipped through Goldbelly. Explore all 12 bagel, brunch and cookie packages. Choose flavors and add-ons where offered. Prices and options are shown on Goldbelly.
Freezer stock-up
Baker’s Dozen Bagels
13 bagels, your choice of flavors. Cream cheese not included.
The simplest way to bring our bagels home. Mix plain, everything, sesame, pumpernickel, French toast and more in one box. Best for stocking the freezer or pairing with your own spreads.
The weekend classic
Baker’s Dozen Bagels + Cream Cheese
13 bagels plus 1 lb. of house-made cream cheese. Lox, fish salad and extra cream cheese available as add-ons.
The classic bagel-and-schmear setup for a weekend breakfast at home. Pick a savory cream cheese like scallion or vegetable, or go sweet with birthday cake or cookie dough.
Brunch for a smaller crew
“East Village” Bagel Brunch for 6
6 bagels plus 2 free, two ½-lb. cream cheeses and ½ lb. of lox. Fixings not included.
A classic New York bagel brunch for six, with your choice of bagels, cream cheese and smoked salmon. Add fish salad or extra cream cheese on Goldbelly.
Double the bagels
Two Baker’s Dozen Bagels
26 bagels, your choice of flavors. Cream cheese not included.
Two baker’s dozen for a house full of bagel lovers or a well-stocked freezer. Mix your favorites and pair them with spreads you already have at home.
A bigger bagel box
Two Baker’s Dozen Bagels + Cream Cheese
26 bagels plus 2 lbs. of cream cheese. Add-ons available.
A generous bagel-and-schmear box for a big family, a long holiday weekend, or splitting between your fridge and freezer.
An NYC bakery classic
Black & White Cookies
Choose 6 or 12 Black & White Cookies, each 5 oz.
Soft, cake-like cookies with half chocolate and half vanilla icing. A classic New York treat to share, send as a gift or keep for yourself.
The full New York treatment
Bagel Brunch Weekender Box for 13
Bagels, lox, cream cheese, whitefish salad, seasoning, cookies. Check Goldbelly for quantities.
The whole spread, dessert included. For a birthday brunch, a holiday morning, or the friend who deserves the full New York treatment.
For the lox lover
“The Eastsider” Salmon Trio Bagel Kit for 6
6 bagels plus 2 free, with ½ lb. each of Nova Scotia salmon, gravlax and pastrami-rub lox. Cream cheese available as an add-on.
Three cured salmon styles side by side, so you can taste the difference between silky Nova, dill-cured gravlax and peppery pastrami lox. Tomato, onion and capers are not included.
The whitefish favorite
Whitefish Salad Bagel Kit for 6
6 bagels, 1 lb. whitefish salad, everything seasoning, capers, onion, tomato and lemon. Cream cheese and lox are add-ons.
A build-your-own whitefish bagel spread with the fixings included. Lemon cannot ship to Arizona or California; check the current product details for your destination.
Bagels-and-lox brunch
“Union Square” Bagel Brunch for 13
13 bagels, three ½-lb. cream cheeses and 1 lb. of lox, with a choice of salmon styles.
A complete bagels-and-lox brunch in one box. Choose gravlax, Nova Scotia, pastrami rub, Scottish double smoked or double smoked. Add your own tomato, red onion and capers and you’re done.
A little of everything
Cookie Sampler – 12 Pack
12 cookies: 4 Black & White Cookies, 4 Sprinkle Cookies and 4 Sugar Cookies.
A shareable assortment of classic New York-style cookies. Mix chocolate-and-vanilla icing with sprinkle and sugar cookies for a sweet gift or dessert spread.
The signature sweet pick
Famous French Toast Bagels – Baker’s Dozen
13 French Toast bagels. Cream cheese not included.
Our signature. Eggs, brown sugar, butter, cinnamon and maple syrup go right into the dough. Toast one and top it with your own birthday cake, cookie dough or roasted apple-cinnamon cream cheese.
Make it your New York breakfast
From Classic Everything Bagels to Sweet NYC Favorites
The lineup covers everything a New Yorker expects and a few things they don’t. Classics include plain, everything, sesame, poppy, onion, salt, whole wheat, whole wheat everything, pumpernickel, multigrain, egg and cinnamon raisin. Then there’s French toast, the bagel we’re best known for, and za’atar on select brunch kits.
Our cream cheeses are whipped in-house. On the savory side: scallion, vegetable, sun-dried tomato, jalapeño cheddar, olive pimento, cucumber dill and chipotle avocado. On the sweet side: birthday cake, chocolate chip cookie dough, fresh roasted apple cinnamon, walnut raisin, strawberry, espresso and more. Plant-based? Select packages offer tofu spreads, too.
Flavor choices depend on the package you pick, and some boxes don’t include cream cheese. Goldbelly shows exactly what’s available before you check out.
Good mornings make great gifts
Send a Taste of New York With Bagel Gifts
A box of bagels says “I thought of you” better than another candle. It’s a gift people actually use, and it turns an ordinary Sunday into an occasion.
Our packages make easy gifts for birthdays, Mother’s Day and Father’s Day, Hanukkah and Christmas morning, thank-yous and get-well wishes, and care packages for college students. They’re especially welcome for anyone who used to live in New York and still talks about the bagels.
On Goldbelly you can ship directly to the recipient’s address, and many packages can also be sent as an email gift that the recipient redeems. Check gift options and delivery dates on each product page.
A few clicks from New York
How to Order NYC Bagels Through Goldbelly
-
01
Browse the shop
Browse the Tompkins Square Bagels packages on Goldbelly.
-
02
Pick your box
Pick a bagel box, brunch kit, specialty dozen or cookie box.
-
03
Make it yours
Choose your bagel flavors and any cream cheese, lox or fish salad add-ons the package offers.
-
04
Add an address
Enter the shipping address, whether that’s your place or a gift recipient’s.
-
05
Choose a date
Pick from the delivery dates Goldbelly shows at checkout.
-
06
Check out
Check out on Goldbelly. Goldbelly handles payment, shipping coordination and order tracking.
Made the old-fashioned way
Five ingredients, a 1950s recipe, hand-rolled and kettle-boiled in small batches. That’s where the chew and the shiny, crackly crust come from.
A real East Village bagel shop
We opened on Avenue A in 2011 and still make bagels for the neighborhood every morning. Owner Christopher Pugliese has been rolling bagels since he was 16.
Cream cheese worth shipping
Our spreads are whipped in-house, from scallion to the birthday cake flavor we helped make famous.
New York’s food press agrees
We’ve been featured in Eater NY, Vogue, Travel + Leisure, Delish and The Infatuation, and named to Grub Street’s list of the absolute best bagels in New York.
Before your box arrives
Nationwide Bagel Shipping FAQs
From choosing your flavors to getting that just-toasted bite. Always check the instructions included with your shipment.
Can I get New York bagels shipped anywhere in the U.S.?
Yes. Tompkins Square Bagels ships nationwide through Goldbelly, and Goldbelly lists our packages as shipping to the U.S. and Canada, with some restrictions. Enter your address at checkout to see availability.
How do I order Tompkins Square Bagels online?
Pick a package on this page and click through to Goldbelly, where you choose flavors, add-ons and a delivery date, then check out.
Can I send bagels as a gift?
Yes. Ship a package straight to the recipient’s address, or use Goldbelly’s email gift option where it’s offered.
Can I choose my bagel and cream cheese flavors?
Most packages let you pick your bagels, and packages with cream cheese let you choose flavors. Options vary by package and are listed on each Goldbelly product page.
How should I store shipped bagels?
Store items in the fridge or freezer when they arrive, following the instructions included with your package. Goldbelly’s TSB instructions say bagels keep up to 3 days refrigerated or up to 2 weeks frozen. Cream cheese and lox keep up to 6 days in the fridge. Kits ship with ice packs, which may thaw in transit.
What’s the best way to reheat them?
Microwave a bagel for 15 to 30 seconds, then slice and toast it. Follow the instructions included with your package.
Are any shipped bagels vegan?
According to Goldbelly’s TSB ingredient note, every bagel except the Egg and French Toast bagels is vegan, and select brunch kits offer tofu spread options. Check the ingredients and choices on your product page before ordering.
Can I order ahead for a holiday?
Goldbelly shows available delivery dates at checkout, so you can pick one ahead of time. Order early around major holidays, when dates fill up.